Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
    Posted by
    
      cnc002@a...
    
  
  
    on 2000-10-24 08:09:34 UTC
  
  Terry:
To answer you question about the ball screw, you don't use a 3/4" ball screw
for a 10' length you use more like 1 to 1- 1/4 inch diameter for that
distance plus keep in mind that your following nut will give some support
even tho it is travelling along the screw. There are many CNC machines out
there with that configuration a lot of the CNC routers used in the
woodworking industry are 5' X 10' travel and use the no backlash ball screws.
However, in your case if you only need +/-.060 tolerance you should have NO
problem using a timing belt for that. You should achieve far better than
that even with a timing belt and it would be far less expensive than any lead
screw assembly you could buy for that distance and you are correct about
being able to compensate in software for most errors.
Regards,
Randy A.
To answer you question about the ball screw, you don't use a 3/4" ball screw
for a 10' length you use more like 1 to 1- 1/4 inch diameter for that
distance plus keep in mind that your following nut will give some support
even tho it is travelling along the screw. There are many CNC machines out
there with that configuration a lot of the CNC routers used in the
woodworking industry are 5' X 10' travel and use the no backlash ball screws.
However, in your case if you only need +/-.060 tolerance you should have NO
problem using a timing belt for that. You should achieve far better than
that even with a timing belt and it would be far less expensive than any lead
screw assembly you could buy for that distance and you are correct about
being able to compensate in software for most errors.
Regards,
Randy A.
Discussion Thread
  
    Terry Toddy
  
2000-10-23 08:26:12 UTC
  Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    cnc002@a...
  
2000-10-23 10:00:19 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    JanRwl@A...
  
2000-10-23 17:30:09 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    Terry Toddy
  
2000-10-24 05:32:15 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    diazden
  
2000-10-24 07:41:47 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    cnc002@a...
  
2000-10-24 08:09:34 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    Smoke
  
2000-10-24 08:22:48 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    Mariss Freimanis
  
2000-10-24 10:02:37 UTC
  Re: Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    Bob Campbell
  
2000-10-24 11:47:28 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    ballendo@y...
  
2000-10-24 18:24:02 UTC
  re:Re: Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    JanRwl@A...
  
2000-10-24 20:36:08 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive
  
    R. T. Robbins
  
2000-10-24 22:09:58 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Timing Belts vs. Rack and Pinion drive