Newbie's Input - Software
Posted by
John Delaney
on 2003-11-22 19:59:47 UTC
So, step one for me has been to make a decision on software and the
controller. I have a simple part that I want to "mass" produce. If ti
sells, I'm off to the races and I can act like a "Pro". Ha! Two axis
would do it, but I'd like three for the next thing.
Here are my thoughts:
If I've offended anyone (like a SW author), sorry, just telling it
like I see it. Take it as free market survey input. BTW - I really DO
appreciate what it takes to write these systems. I am impressed with
them all. I just need to make a call for my needs.
Visio Able to save to DXF. I am 99% sure that I can do my part in
this with some creative applications of tools and drilling, etc. I
REALLY want Corel. So this might be the excuse to get it ..:-)
DeskKAM Seems to be able to process files like what I need to do
the part. Will not import crap from TurboCad8's DXF. But then again I
know that their DXF sucks.
DeskWinNC Seemed to take the DNC files from DesKAM. Not sure what
else to say about that one.
DeskCNC - integrates DesKAM and DeskWinNC It's better, smoother
with built in tools in the contour and pocket generators. $350.00 w-
the controller. So I think I'm out the door for about $2300.00 with
this one INCLUDING MOTORS. Still need cables and other stuff.
Mach2 - looks pretty rough still. Messed up my Windows. Hung bad
importing a .BMP. Hung during it's own regen of g-codes on my big
Dell. Give it about another year. But the inteface is sexy!
EMC CNC only I think. Still need a CAM program to gen the G-Codes.
Then I am not at all sure I am up to the whole Linux thing. I hate
Bill Gates too but how much work is that really worth?
Simple G has a nice simulator. I'm having trouble figuring out what
it uses as a driver.
Sent them an e-mail about that. But I still need a CAM package.
DeskCNC has both.
http://www.datapulsesoftware.com/
Ahha! Artisan CNC DOS based. Boy will that fly on my 2 ghz Dell
server! It looks fine. The graphics are less than ideal, but what do
you expect from a DOS program. I still want a Windows based CAM
program to gen the G-Code files and paths. Ahha sells the whole deal.
Software and the final controller. $984 for the software and the
controller card. Then I still need the Geckos & stuff. Final
controller/driver from Ahha is $1975 + $575 for the 3rd Axis. That's
$984+$9175+$575 = $3534.00 PLUS MOTORS. WOW! Too much for me.
http://www.ahha.com/index.htm
Supertech They have SuperCAM CNC software which drive that
parallel port and they have a controller. Cheapest bundle for the
software and controller is $1495.00 for servo control, $1695.00 for
stepper control.
So the SuperCam demo won't run under XP Want '95 / '98.
After reading their poop sheet I see that it does not generate G-
Codes. Not sure I like that. G-Codes, as funky as they may be, are
standard. If I decide to go have something done at a shop having a G-
Code file might be handy.
http://www.super-tech.com/
So it looks like DeskCNC here we go. Probably going to go with
the Gecko's as I see them around a lot.
If I'm being dumb, please let me know.
Thanks,
-jd
controller. I have a simple part that I want to "mass" produce. If ti
sells, I'm off to the races and I can act like a "Pro". Ha! Two axis
would do it, but I'd like three for the next thing.
Here are my thoughts:
If I've offended anyone (like a SW author), sorry, just telling it
like I see it. Take it as free market survey input. BTW - I really DO
appreciate what it takes to write these systems. I am impressed with
them all. I just need to make a call for my needs.
Visio Able to save to DXF. I am 99% sure that I can do my part in
this with some creative applications of tools and drilling, etc. I
REALLY want Corel. So this might be the excuse to get it ..:-)
DeskKAM Seems to be able to process files like what I need to do
the part. Will not import crap from TurboCad8's DXF. But then again I
know that their DXF sucks.
DeskWinNC Seemed to take the DNC files from DesKAM. Not sure what
else to say about that one.
DeskCNC - integrates DesKAM and DeskWinNC It's better, smoother
with built in tools in the contour and pocket generators. $350.00 w-
the controller. So I think I'm out the door for about $2300.00 with
this one INCLUDING MOTORS. Still need cables and other stuff.
Mach2 - looks pretty rough still. Messed up my Windows. Hung bad
importing a .BMP. Hung during it's own regen of g-codes on my big
Dell. Give it about another year. But the inteface is sexy!
EMC CNC only I think. Still need a CAM program to gen the G-Codes.
Then I am not at all sure I am up to the whole Linux thing. I hate
Bill Gates too but how much work is that really worth?
Simple G has a nice simulator. I'm having trouble figuring out what
it uses as a driver.
Sent them an e-mail about that. But I still need a CAM package.
DeskCNC has both.
http://www.datapulsesoftware.com/
Ahha! Artisan CNC DOS based. Boy will that fly on my 2 ghz Dell
server! It looks fine. The graphics are less than ideal, but what do
you expect from a DOS program. I still want a Windows based CAM
program to gen the G-Code files and paths. Ahha sells the whole deal.
Software and the final controller. $984 for the software and the
controller card. Then I still need the Geckos & stuff. Final
controller/driver from Ahha is $1975 + $575 for the 3rd Axis. That's
$984+$9175+$575 = $3534.00 PLUS MOTORS. WOW! Too much for me.
http://www.ahha.com/index.htm
Supertech They have SuperCAM CNC software which drive that
parallel port and they have a controller. Cheapest bundle for the
software and controller is $1495.00 for servo control, $1695.00 for
stepper control.
So the SuperCam demo won't run under XP Want '95 / '98.
After reading their poop sheet I see that it does not generate G-
Codes. Not sure I like that. G-Codes, as funky as they may be, are
standard. If I decide to go have something done at a shop having a G-
Code file might be handy.
http://www.super-tech.com/
So it looks like DeskCNC here we go. Probably going to go with
the Gecko's as I see them around a lot.
If I'm being dumb, please let me know.
Thanks,
-jd
Discussion Thread
John Delaney
2003-11-22 19:59:47 UTC
Newbie's Input - Software
John Johnson
2003-11-22 21:44:10 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Newbie's Input - Software
Ray Henry
2003-11-23 08:01:29 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software
John Delaney
2003-11-23 13:59:45 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software
John Delaney
2003-11-23 14:19:39 UTC
Waffle - Newbie's Input - Software
turbulatordude
2003-11-23 18:52:07 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software
Tim Goldstein
2003-11-23 19:15:39 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Newbie's Input - Software
Tim Goldstein
2003-11-23 19:15:40 UTC
New moderator for the CCED list
John Delaney
2003-11-25 20:03:28 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software - Mach2
Charles Hixon
2003-11-25 20:30:16 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software
John Delaney
2003-11-25 21:40:05 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software
Charles Hixon
2003-11-26 07:19:41 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software
John Delaney
2003-11-26 14:07:18 UTC
Re: Newbie's Input - Software