Differences between AC & DC brushless
Posted by
bitnick78
on 2004-03-25 05:40:03 UTC
Except for encoder type, are there really any differences between a
DC brushless motor and an AC brushless motor? (I'm talking about
servo motors here, not motors driven by a VFD or the mains.)
If I have understood things correctly, the difference is really in
the way the motor is driven -
* it's a DC brushless motor if the commutation is trapezoidal (which
require hall effect sensors or other low-resolution absolute
feedback).
* it's an AC (brushless) motor if the commutation is sinusoidal
(which require some kind of higher-resolution absolute or semi-
absolute feedback device).
If this is correct, then I wonder what is the result of using the
different drive methods? How much "better", and in what ways, is the
AC approach?
Arvid
DC brushless motor and an AC brushless motor? (I'm talking about
servo motors here, not motors driven by a VFD or the mains.)
If I have understood things correctly, the difference is really in
the way the motor is driven -
* it's a DC brushless motor if the commutation is trapezoidal (which
require hall effect sensors or other low-resolution absolute
feedback).
* it's an AC (brushless) motor if the commutation is sinusoidal
(which require some kind of higher-resolution absolute or semi-
absolute feedback device).
If this is correct, then I wonder what is the result of using the
different drive methods? How much "better", and in what ways, is the
AC approach?
Arvid
Discussion Thread
bitnick78
2004-03-25 05:40:03 UTC
Differences between AC & DC brushless
Jon Elson
2004-03-25 09:44:20 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Differences between AC & DC brushless
bitnick78
2004-03-25 13:06:38 UTC
Re: Differences between AC & DC brushless
vavaroutsos
2004-03-25 16:04:04 UTC
Re: Differences between AC & DC brushless
Jon Elson
2004-03-25 22:02:07 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Differences between AC & DC brushless
Roy J. Tellason
2004-03-25 23:17:24 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Differences between AC & DC brushless
Jon Elson
2004-03-26 08:38:26 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Differences between AC & DC brushless