Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
Posted by
tom.kay@n...
on 2001-11-05 07:26:38 UTC
I am converting a mill to cnc with Dan Mauch's 5 amp boards and his
521 oz-in stepper motors. I plan on using a 2:1 reduction from the
motors to the screw. Software, probably Master5 from Art Fenerty.
I have heard that steppers need some load, or "drag" resistance to
operate happily, or they will tend to overshoot their steps. This may
be less of a problem with Mariss's 10 microstepping gecko drives, but
the boards I have only do full or half step. Someone actually told me
to install some little friction brakes on my x and y axes, so that
the motors don't overshoot. This person mentioned that it would be
less necessary if I used a pulley/belt reduction, presumably because
this adds some friction, or because losing a step isn't is big a
problem???
And related, would be a choice between ballscrews or leadscrews with
anti-backlash plastic nuts. I know ballscrews are about 95 percent
efficient (they won't even stay put unless locked), and leadscrews
are closer to 50 percent, but has anyone got a suggestion there? The
leadscrews would certainly provide a built-in drag force, if that's
needed (and not pure bunk).
Thanks all, Tom Kay.
521 oz-in stepper motors. I plan on using a 2:1 reduction from the
motors to the screw. Software, probably Master5 from Art Fenerty.
I have heard that steppers need some load, or "drag" resistance to
operate happily, or they will tend to overshoot their steps. This may
be less of a problem with Mariss's 10 microstepping gecko drives, but
the boards I have only do full or half step. Someone actually told me
to install some little friction brakes on my x and y axes, so that
the motors don't overshoot. This person mentioned that it would be
less necessary if I used a pulley/belt reduction, presumably because
this adds some friction, or because losing a step isn't is big a
problem???
And related, would be a choice between ballscrews or leadscrews with
anti-backlash plastic nuts. I know ballscrews are about 95 percent
efficient (they won't even stay put unless locked), and leadscrews
are closer to 50 percent, but has anyone got a suggestion there? The
leadscrews would certainly provide a built-in drag force, if that's
needed (and not pure bunk).
Thanks all, Tom Kay.
Discussion Thread
tom.kay@n...
2001-11-05 07:26:38 UTC
Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
stevesng@n...
2001-11-05 08:25:44 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
tom.kay@n...
2001-11-05 08:53:37 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
stevesng@n...
2001-11-05 09:46:24 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
currinh@O...
2001-11-05 09:47:55 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
tom.kay@n...
2001-11-05 10:10:12 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
currinh@O...
2001-11-05 13:05:46 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
Peter Seddon
2001-11-05 13:16:44 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
allan_r9@h...
2001-11-05 14:30:45 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"
stevesng@n...
2001-11-05 21:09:17 UTC
Re: Do Stepper Motors need "Drag?"