Easing Into CNC -- Ball Screws?
Posted by
Paul R. Hvidston
on 2001-11-12 09:11:27 UTC
I'd like to solicit some words of wisdom from the group.
I decided it was time to join the group since I'm considering moving towards
making my RF-31 dual-use. Here's the relevant background: As a consulting
engineer, I've done a lot of automation system design and implementation,
most recently (several years back) as a certified system integrator for
Cimetrix -- awesome software, poor company (IMO). All of my work was in the
area of micron-precision equipment. Anyway, just to keep playing with
computer control, I want to incrementally (cheaply) add CNC to my RF-31.
I've got an industrial PC that I'll be loading LinuxCNC (NIST EMC), and I
can put together the stepper controllers and power supplies, so that's not a
problem. However, even after searching through the message archives, I'm
still wondering if I can "get away" with retaining the stock lead-screws and
nuts for the near term. I understand some of the issues of backlash
(climb-milling and accuracy), but given that I can minimize backlash with
bearing pre-load and a well-adjusted nut (:-o), what else is there to worry
about if using acme screws instead of ball screws? Friction? Would I need
much bigger steppers to offset friction (eating up any savings in lead
screws)? Your advice cheerfully accepted.
Thanks,
Paul R. Hvidston, N6MGN
ACKSYS Engineering
Upland, CA
I decided it was time to join the group since I'm considering moving towards
making my RF-31 dual-use. Here's the relevant background: As a consulting
engineer, I've done a lot of automation system design and implementation,
most recently (several years back) as a certified system integrator for
Cimetrix -- awesome software, poor company (IMO). All of my work was in the
area of micron-precision equipment. Anyway, just to keep playing with
computer control, I want to incrementally (cheaply) add CNC to my RF-31.
I've got an industrial PC that I'll be loading LinuxCNC (NIST EMC), and I
can put together the stepper controllers and power supplies, so that's not a
problem. However, even after searching through the message archives, I'm
still wondering if I can "get away" with retaining the stock lead-screws and
nuts for the near term. I understand some of the issues of backlash
(climb-milling and accuracy), but given that I can minimize backlash with
bearing pre-load and a well-adjusted nut (:-o), what else is there to worry
about if using acme screws instead of ball screws? Friction? Would I need
much bigger steppers to offset friction (eating up any savings in lead
screws)? Your advice cheerfully accepted.
Thanks,
Paul R. Hvidston, N6MGN
ACKSYS Engineering
Upland, CA
Discussion Thread
Paul R. Hvidston
2001-11-12 09:11:27 UTC
Easing Into CNC -- Ball Screws?
currinh@O...
2001-11-12 17:22:20 UTC
Re: Easing Into CNC -- Ball Screws?
Paul R. Hvidston
2001-11-12 18:03:12 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Easing Into CNC -- Ball Screws?
Deon Styger
2001-11-12 23:27:53 UTC
RE: Easing Into CNC -- Ball Screws?
thscarince@h...
2001-11-13 06:45:33 UTC
Re: Easing Into CNC -- Ball Screws?