Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
Posted by
scyvt
on 2002-05-27 15:35:03 UTC
Hello list
When the speed of a spindle drive motor is reduced by step or variable
diameter pulleys, the torque is multiplied by the same ratio that the
speed is reduced. In other words, lower speed - higher torque. This is
consistent with what is needed by machine tools.
But when spindle speed is reduced by reducing motor speed using a VFD,
torque is reduced in the same proportion as speed, isn't it? In other
words, lower speed - lower torque.
But VFD's have been recommended on this list, and most new commercial
CNC machines seem to control spindle speed this way. So how can this
be?
I am retrofitting a lathe that had an elaborate mechanical variable
speed drive, and it would a lot easier to go the VFD route, especially
so CSS could be implemented. But I just don't see how there could not
be a lack of power at lower speeds. What am I missing?
TIA,
Steve Clay-Young
When the speed of a spindle drive motor is reduced by step or variable
diameter pulleys, the torque is multiplied by the same ratio that the
speed is reduced. In other words, lower speed - higher torque. This is
consistent with what is needed by machine tools.
But when spindle speed is reduced by reducing motor speed using a VFD,
torque is reduced in the same proportion as speed, isn't it? In other
words, lower speed - lower torque.
But VFD's have been recommended on this list, and most new commercial
CNC machines seem to control spindle speed this way. So how can this
be?
I am retrofitting a lathe that had an elaborate mechanical variable
speed drive, and it would a lot easier to go the VFD route, especially
so CSS could be implemented. But I just don't see how there could not
be a lack of power at lower speeds. What am I missing?
TIA,
Steve Clay-Young
Discussion Thread
scyvt
2002-05-27 15:35:03 UTC
Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
Carol & Jerry Jankura
2002-05-27 16:23:54 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
steveggca
2002-05-27 17:12:23 UTC
Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
doug98105
2002-05-27 19:21:50 UTC
Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
bsptrades
2002-05-27 21:23:43 UTC
Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
Jon Elson
2002-05-27 22:43:52 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
scyvt
2002-05-28 17:36:14 UTC
Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
Marcus & Eva
2002-05-28 19:26:06 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
Doug Fortune
2002-05-28 20:54:59 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
bsptrades
2002-05-28 22:15:48 UTC
Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
doug98105
2002-05-28 22:16:09 UTC
Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?
bsptrades
2002-05-29 13:32:23 UTC
Re: Adequate torque from VFD driven motors?