CNC Controller Software Review
Posted by
Chris and Dee
on 2002-10-09 09:51:49 UTC
Hello again,
I would venture a guess that the question I'm about to ask is
answered many times over and for that I apologize. If there is a
review somewhere that somebody could point me to, it would be much
appreciated.
That said, I'm preparing to construct my first CNC benchtop mill
(Enco Mill - picking it up on Sunday). I've accumulated the drives,
the stepper motors, power supply and have dusted off the old P166 I
put in the attic. Once I get the machine, I plan to construct my
motor mounts and try to get started using the standard ACME lead
screws. All that's left, then, is to get the CNC controller
software. All along, I've been thinking of using TurboCNC because
from what I've read, it looks reasonably complete and the price can't
be beat. But I thought I'd try to get the opinions of the list
first. Here are some CNC controllers that I've identified with some
basic comments and prices. Obviously I'm looking to do this
reasonably inexpensively (aren't we all) so $2k packages are out of
the question. What are people's experiences (preferrably BAD
experieces since that's what I'm trying to prevent) with the
following packages:
Software Price Comments
TurboCNC $20 Baseling
EzCNC $20 VERY limited G-Codes, Runs in Windows
DeskNC $75 Limited G-codes
Supercam $495 Limited G-codes, dongle, includes CAD,
more for engraving
Stepster Free ?
Master5 $100 Good G-code support, Windows, req. 300Mhz
Pentium, DXF import, 8000 SPS
Mach1 ? Win2000, good G-Code support, Alpha stage
CNCPro $200 Good G-code support
CNCProLite $150 Same as above but lacks a number of G-codes
LinuxEMC Free Need Linux box and Linux knowledge
Thanks for your help!!
-Chris
http://www.slideruleracing.com
I would venture a guess that the question I'm about to ask is
answered many times over and for that I apologize. If there is a
review somewhere that somebody could point me to, it would be much
appreciated.
That said, I'm preparing to construct my first CNC benchtop mill
(Enco Mill - picking it up on Sunday). I've accumulated the drives,
the stepper motors, power supply and have dusted off the old P166 I
put in the attic. Once I get the machine, I plan to construct my
motor mounts and try to get started using the standard ACME lead
screws. All that's left, then, is to get the CNC controller
software. All along, I've been thinking of using TurboCNC because
from what I've read, it looks reasonably complete and the price can't
be beat. But I thought I'd try to get the opinions of the list
first. Here are some CNC controllers that I've identified with some
basic comments and prices. Obviously I'm looking to do this
reasonably inexpensively (aren't we all) so $2k packages are out of
the question. What are people's experiences (preferrably BAD
experieces since that's what I'm trying to prevent) with the
following packages:
Software Price Comments
TurboCNC $20 Baseling
EzCNC $20 VERY limited G-Codes, Runs in Windows
DeskNC $75 Limited G-codes
Supercam $495 Limited G-codes, dongle, includes CAD,
more for engraving
Stepster Free ?
Master5 $100 Good G-code support, Windows, req. 300Mhz
Pentium, DXF import, 8000 SPS
Mach1 ? Win2000, good G-Code support, Alpha stage
CNCPro $200 Good G-code support
CNCProLite $150 Same as above but lacks a number of G-codes
LinuxEMC Free Need Linux box and Linux knowledge
Thanks for your help!!
-Chris
http://www.slideruleracing.com
Discussion Thread
Chris and Dee
2002-10-09 09:51:49 UTC
CNC Controller Software Review
j.guenther
2002-10-09 10:02:01 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] CNC Controller Software Review
Rick E
2002-10-09 10:26:29 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] CNC Controller Software Review
Fred Smith
2002-10-10 12:37:19 UTC
Re: CNC Controller Software Review