Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
Posted by
kstropus
on 2007-08-04 14:17:40 UTC
My primary interest is in building the controller. Stepper
controllers seem much more complicated compared to servo controllers.
All I have to do with a servo controller (it seems to me) is move it
forward or reverse until I count the steps I need then keep it there.
With steppers I have to deal with micro stepping, resonance, and all
sorts of other junk I don't need to mess with when I have a much more
simpler option.
And I don't really understand why everyone says steppers are cheaper.
I can buy surplus dc motors and encoders dirt cheap and put a servo
together myself. Steppers are so damn expensive, plus everyone and
his brother is running a hobby cnc web site or ebay store selling
steppers, which means they buy up all the surplus stepper supply and
resell them at twice the price. I don't really see many of them
selling servo systems.
However, I have invested a tremendous amount of research in steppers,
so I'm more than happy to listen if anyone thinks I'm off base here
and wants to set me straight.
--- In CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@yahoogroups.com, "Andrey Lipavsky"
<alipavsky@...> wrote:
controllers seem much more complicated compared to servo controllers.
All I have to do with a servo controller (it seems to me) is move it
forward or reverse until I count the steps I need then keep it there.
With steppers I have to deal with micro stepping, resonance, and all
sorts of other junk I don't need to mess with when I have a much more
simpler option.
And I don't really understand why everyone says steppers are cheaper.
I can buy surplus dc motors and encoders dirt cheap and put a servo
together myself. Steppers are so damn expensive, plus everyone and
his brother is running a hobby cnc web site or ebay store selling
steppers, which means they buy up all the surplus stepper supply and
resell them at twice the price. I don't really see many of them
selling servo systems.
However, I have invested a tremendous amount of research in steppers,
so I'm more than happy to listen if anyone thinks I'm off base here
and wants to set me straight.
--- In CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@yahoogroups.com, "Andrey Lipavsky"
<alipavsky@...> wrote:
>steppers?
> If you're looking for the least expensive way to go, why not use
>
> Thanks,
> Andrey Lipavsky
> Essex Jewelers
> 490 E. McMillan St.
> Studio 205
> Cincinnati, OH 45206
> (513) 826-0240
> www.essexjewelers.com
Discussion Thread
kstropus
2007-08-03 17:49:40 UTC
Dual shaft dc motor supplier
Andrey Lipavsky
2007-08-03 23:12:01 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Dual shaft dc motor supplier
Bill
2007-08-04 09:08:09 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
kstropus
2007-08-04 14:17:40 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
kstropus
2007-08-04 14:19:49 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
caudlet
2007-08-04 20:47:54 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
Bill
2007-08-04 20:48:52 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
Andrey Lipavsky
2007-08-04 23:10:07 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
kstropus
2007-08-05 18:42:36 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
kstropus
2007-08-05 18:45:38 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
Graham Stabler
2007-08-06 03:08:52 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier
kstropus
2007-08-06 09:24:18 UTC
Re: Dual shaft dc motor supplier