Re: What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?
Posted by
fast1994gto
on 2002-02-16 11:50:21 UTC
I doubt there is a measurable difference all other things being equal.
You require a good thermal contact between the heatsink and the heat
source. A conservative amount of compund is all that is required
since its prupose is to fill in the microscopic peaks and valleys of
the mating surfaces. Silver paste is great but others work well too.
Copper takes heat away better, but aluminum dissipates heat better.
The best heatsinks I have used have a copper contact area mated to an
aluminum sink. That's getting to be overkill for the Geckos unless
you are running them at the ragged edge of their capacity.
I run my Geckos at 2A without heatsinks (although they do mate
against the wall of a thin metal case, and I did use zinc heatsink
compound) and they are barely get warm to the touch even after
extended use.
Barry
You require a good thermal contact between the heatsink and the heat
source. A conservative amount of compund is all that is required
since its prupose is to fill in the microscopic peaks and valleys of
the mating surfaces. Silver paste is great but others work well too.
Copper takes heat away better, but aluminum dissipates heat better.
The best heatsinks I have used have a copper contact area mated to an
aluminum sink. That's getting to be overkill for the Geckos unless
you are running them at the ragged edge of their capacity.
I run my Geckos at 2A without heatsinks (although they do mate
against the wall of a thin metal case, and I did use zinc heatsink
compound) and they are barely get warm to the touch even after
extended use.
Barry
--- In CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@y..., "Lloyd Leung" <lloyd@l...> wrote:
> I'm wondering what's a better heatsink for my geckos.
>
> Assuming that both heatsinks are aluminium with same number and
size of
> fins, with same sized base, which is better?
>
> I'm just talking about heat dissipation, not costs.
Discussion Thread
Lloyd Leung
2002-02-16 11:33:18 UTC
What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?
fast1994gto
2002-02-16 11:50:21 UTC
Re: What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?
mariss92705
2002-02-16 13:38:49 UTC
Re: What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?
Bill Vance
2002-02-16 14:19:32 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?
Jon Elson
2002-02-16 18:24:01 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?
rainnea
2002-02-17 03:00:04 UTC
Re: What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?
n4onl
2002-02-17 23:09:37 UTC
Re: What's better, extruded heatsinks or machines heatsinks?