Z-Axis Knee Woes
    Posted by
    
      jbordens <jake@a...
    
  
  
    on 2003-01-13 16:58:46 UTC
  
  Hi folks.  I'm retrofitting a G3102 Grizzly Knee Mill, a smaller type
mill somewhere bigger than a drill mill, but smaller than a full
bridgeport.
I just finished my Z-axis, after success with X and Y. I decided to
motorize the knee for various reasons. I'm using Camtronics 600-in-oz
motors and a 2:1 ratio on the pulleys.
The knee is driven by a shaft that is at 90-degrees to a jackscrew.
The shaft is connected to the jackscrew via a set of helical spur gears.
Here are my problems:
(1) the motors aren't powerful enough, apparently, to raise the knee.
They stall and eventually cause my geckos to fault. I'm pretty sure
I have the "limit" set to Max on the geckos.
(2) when lowering the knee, the motor turns and every now again
there's a 'thump' from the mill, as if the knee is not lowering
smoothly, but in little increments.
I guess I have two options:
(a) go to a higher ratio, but 2:1 was the most practical. 3:1 is
possible but expensive, and anything more is really not possible due
to pulley size constraints.
(b) counterweight the knee. I think this is complicated and probably
not a good idea.
In either case I'm not sure it would solve problem #2. I'm currently
at a loss on how to proceed. Any suggestions are greatly apprecaited.
Thanks,
Jake
mill somewhere bigger than a drill mill, but smaller than a full
bridgeport.
I just finished my Z-axis, after success with X and Y. I decided to
motorize the knee for various reasons. I'm using Camtronics 600-in-oz
motors and a 2:1 ratio on the pulleys.
The knee is driven by a shaft that is at 90-degrees to a jackscrew.
The shaft is connected to the jackscrew via a set of helical spur gears.
Here are my problems:
(1) the motors aren't powerful enough, apparently, to raise the knee.
They stall and eventually cause my geckos to fault. I'm pretty sure
I have the "limit" set to Max on the geckos.
(2) when lowering the knee, the motor turns and every now again
there's a 'thump' from the mill, as if the knee is not lowering
smoothly, but in little increments.
I guess I have two options:
(a) go to a higher ratio, but 2:1 was the most practical. 3:1 is
possible but expensive, and anything more is really not possible due
to pulley size constraints.
(b) counterweight the knee. I think this is complicated and probably
not a good idea.
In either case I'm not sure it would solve problem #2. I'm currently
at a loss on how to proceed. Any suggestions are greatly apprecaited.
Thanks,
Jake
Discussion Thread
  
    jbordens <jake@a...
  
2003-01-13 16:58:46 UTC
  Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Brian
  
2003-01-13 18:15:44 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    torsten98001 <torsten@g...
  
2003-01-13 18:19:21 UTC
  Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    George Erhart
  
2003-01-13 18:22:20 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    mjf462001 <mjf46@j...
  
2003-01-13 19:10:35 UTC
  Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Mariss Freimanis <mariss92705@y...
  
2003-01-13 19:16:16 UTC
  Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Vince Negrete
  
2003-01-13 19:24:09 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Bernard R <bwjarandall@c...
  
2003-01-13 19:47:23 UTC
  Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Mariss Freimanis <mariss92705@y...
  
2003-01-13 20:23:54 UTC
  Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Raymond Heckert
  
2003-01-13 20:35:47 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Peter
  
2003-01-13 20:50:47 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Jon Elson
  
2003-01-13 23:27:30 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Vince Negrete
  
2003-01-14 00:48:10 UTC
  More Questions on Z-Axis Drive
  
    Marv Frankel
  
2003-01-14 03:06:10 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Les Watts
  
2003-01-14 04:55:01 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Jon Elson
  
2003-01-14 10:14:35 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] More Questions on Z-Axis Drive
  
    Dan Mauch
  
2003-01-14 12:14:24 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Bernard R <bwjarandall@c...
  
2003-01-14 17:04:15 UTC
  Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Bernard R <bwjarandall@c...
  
2003-01-14 18:19:00 UTC
  Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes
  
    Les Watts
  
2003-01-14 19:04:51 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Z-Axis Knee Woes