Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
    Posted by
    
      ja_erickson
    
  
  
    on 2002-03-10 17:57:04 UTC
  
  Evening All,
GOOD NEWS !!! Mariss suggested that i change from using a seperate
power supply to the game port power out and it corrected the lost
stepping and intermittent stalling. when i put a voltmeter from
direction to ground i had voltages of .756 and 3.38 during
directional changes. if these voltages are supposed to be 0 and 5
volts then something is still in error.by the way i have constructed
the current dump circuitry and have also implemented this.when this
motor is running it runs very smoothly at feedrates of 10 i.p.m. or
greater in any direction , however at feedrates below this the motor
still growls and sounds unhappy but hasn't lost any steps YET.is
there any other procedures that i can do to eliminate this? i have
tried the trim but theres not enough trim to be had !!!! haha
i'd also like to thank each of you for your help and insights
jeff
GOOD NEWS !!! Mariss suggested that i change from using a seperate
power supply to the game port power out and it corrected the lost
stepping and intermittent stalling. when i put a voltmeter from
direction to ground i had voltages of .756 and 3.38 during
directional changes. if these voltages are supposed to be 0 and 5
volts then something is still in error.by the way i have constructed
the current dump circuitry and have also implemented this.when this
motor is running it runs very smoothly at feedrates of 10 i.p.m. or
greater in any direction , however at feedrates below this the motor
still growls and sounds unhappy but hasn't lost any steps YET.is
there any other procedures that i can do to eliminate this? i have
tried the trim but theres not enough trim to be had !!!! haha
i'd also like to thank each of you for your help and insights
jeff
--- In CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@y..., "mariss92705" <mariss92705@y...> wrote:
> Art,
>
> Not to worry. The multipliers were originally designed for point to
> point operation; machine stops, change direction, go again.
>
> People started using them for constant contouring.
>
> That required a revision so that each sent step is "tagged" with
its
> direction. When the step executes, it goes in the direction it was
> tagged with. That was done on REV-4, 3 months ago. No more problems.
>
> The next revision will have it tagged 4 steps deep. The only way to
> spoof it then will be to change direction 4 times while
accelerating.
> Not a realistic situation.
>
> Though it was never designed to do constant contouring, with REV-4
it
> has been able to, based on reports and extensive testing here.
> Because I am paranoid about this, REV-5 will quadruple-nail this
> situation shut.
>
> You are taking care of this in software. The REV-4 (current
version)
> takes care of it in hardware as well.
>
> Mariss
>
> --- In CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@y..., "Art Fenerty" <fenerty@h...> wrote:
> > Surprisingly enough I have had this complaint before. It is
usually
> the
> > step/dir pins being swapped or the polarity is wrong. Gecko's do
> indeed need
> > special handling of the DIR bit ( Actually, it must be held on as
> long as
> > the multiplied pulse train) but Master5 takes this into account.
> (Couldn't
> > have it NOT run Marisses drives..that would be kiss of death).
> >
> > Try swapping step/dir or polarity and see what happens.
> >
> > Good luck,
> > Art
> > Master5 Software
> > http://users.andara.com/~fenerty/master.htm
Discussion Thread
  
    ja_erickson
  
2002-03-10 12:48:39 UTC
  INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    mariss92705
  
2002-03-10 13:10:58 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    ja_erickson
  
2002-03-10 14:14:11 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    Robert Allen
  
2002-03-10 14:34:07 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    mariss92705
  
2002-03-10 15:19:08 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    Jon Elson
  
2002-03-10 15:38:38 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    Art Fenerty
  
2002-03-10 15:54:38 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    Bob Campbell
  
2002-03-10 16:17:25 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    mariss92705
  
2002-03-10 16:45:34 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    ja_erickson
  
2002-03-10 17:37:45 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    ja_erickson
  
2002-03-10 17:57:04 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    ja_erickson
  
2002-03-10 17:58:40 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    mariss92705
  
2002-03-10 17:59:25 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    mariss92705
  
2002-03-10 18:06:50 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    Hugh Currin
  
2002-03-10 19:22:00 UTC
  Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    destine300@a...
  
2002-03-10 20:12:18 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    Jon Elson
  
2002-03-10 23:10:16 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION
  
    Jon Elson
  
2002-03-10 23:13:45 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] INCONSISTENT STEPPING - WIERD SITUATION