General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Posted by
Statman Designs, LLC
on 2003-06-26 07:15:33 UTC
I often hear a lot about the limitations of stepper motor systems being the
potential for lost steps and the resonance issues at low speed. I have a
question for those of you running stepper motor CNC machines: do any of you
actually miss and steps? My systems have been up and running many, many
hours and have never missed a step. With a micro-stepping drive like
Xylotex (for small machines) or Gecko (for larger machines) isn't the
resonance issue resolved? I have zero low-speed resonance on my sytems with
the Xylotex drives.
I think the fact that steppers lose torque at high-speed is the only
limitation that seems to matter. Therefore, a stepper system will be
somewhat slower than a servo system. Or am I missing something else?
Not trying to start a religious war about stepper and servo systems, just
trying to understand the real differences.
Daniel J. Statman, Statman Designs
www.statmandesigns.com
dan.statman@...
potential for lost steps and the resonance issues at low speed. I have a
question for those of you running stepper motor CNC machines: do any of you
actually miss and steps? My systems have been up and running many, many
hours and have never missed a step. With a micro-stepping drive like
Xylotex (for small machines) or Gecko (for larger machines) isn't the
resonance issue resolved? I have zero low-speed resonance on my sytems with
the Xylotex drives.
I think the fact that steppers lose torque at high-speed is the only
limitation that seems to matter. Therefore, a stepper system will be
somewhat slower than a servo system. Or am I missing something else?
Not trying to start a religious war about stepper and servo systems, just
trying to understand the real differences.
Daniel J. Statman, Statman Designs
www.statmandesigns.com
dan.statman@...
Discussion Thread
Statman Designs, LLC
2003-06-26 07:15:33 UTC
General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Markwayne
2003-06-26 07:50:12 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Charles Hixon
2003-06-26 08:01:08 UTC
Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Tim Goldstein
2003-06-26 08:05:15 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Tim Goldstein
2003-06-26 08:13:05 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Les Newell
2003-06-26 08:36:36 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Charles Hixon
2003-06-26 09:25:09 UTC
Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Tim Goldstein
2003-06-26 11:11:59 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Charles Hixon
2003-06-26 11:44:06 UTC
Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
JanRwl@A...
2003-06-26 14:18:25 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Jeff Lionberger
2003-06-26 15:20:00 UTC
Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
IMService
2003-06-26 16:26:37 UTC
Re: Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
fortino
2003-06-27 08:20:47 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Torsten
2003-06-27 09:33:04 UTC
Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Charles Hixon
2003-06-27 09:51:02 UTC
Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
andyolney
2003-06-27 10:19:35 UTC
Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Marcus
2003-06-27 10:56:46 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Alan Marconett KM6VV
2003-06-27 11:28:23 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Fred Smith
2003-06-27 11:51:36 UTC
Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Charles Hixon
2003-06-27 13:54:28 UTC
Re: equation for locating the center of an arc knowing three points
Alan Marconett KM6VV
2003-06-27 16:21:51 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: equation for locating the center of an arc knowing three points
Kim Lux
2003-06-27 16:40:44 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: equation for locating the center of an arc knowing three points
Charles Hixon
2003-06-27 18:42:20 UTC
Re: equation for locating the center of an arc knowing three points
R Petersen
2003-06-27 18:45:08 UTC
Parker systems
Jon Elson
2003-06-27 19:25:38 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Bill Price
2003-06-27 19:54:49 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Charles Hixon
2003-06-28 06:40:50 UTC
Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Mariss Freimanis
2003-06-28 10:51:35 UTC
Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Raymond Heckert
2003-06-28 18:00:00 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Charles Hixon
2003-06-28 19:47:46 UTC
Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs
Jon Elson
2003-06-28 21:43:44 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: General Question REgarding Stepper vs. Servos
Jeff Lionberger
2003-06-30 09:50:29 UTC
[CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Filter or converter for converting short lines to arcs