Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Posted by
David Bloomfield
on 2006-12-20 04:09:10 UTC
We really do need very high feedback resulutions/pulse frequencies.
The actual resolution required for a dynamic servo system is MUCH
higher than the required machining tolerance. I believe the rule of
thumb is 10x higher but more is better. As mentioned earlier, modern
servo drives do not use tachometers to measure velocity. The digital
controller/drive must see multiple encoder counts to determine
velocity, and more still to calculate acceleration. These values are
pushed into the feed forward loops to maintain position even during
high accelerations where a typical PID loop may not be sufficient. I
think it is the end goal to have Mach-3 come as close as possible to
one of the expensive commercial systems from a company like Fanuc. If
that is what we're going for, then we need all the help we can get :)
The actual resolution required for a dynamic servo system is MUCH
higher than the required machining tolerance. I believe the rule of
thumb is 10x higher but more is better. As mentioned earlier, modern
servo drives do not use tachometers to measure velocity. The digital
controller/drive must see multiple encoder counts to determine
velocity, and more still to calculate acceleration. These values are
pushed into the feed forward loops to maintain position even during
high accelerations where a typical PID loop may not be sufficient. I
think it is the end goal to have Mach-3 come as close as possible to
one of the expensive commercial systems from a company like Fanuc. If
that is what we're going for, then we need all the help we can get :)
Discussion Thread
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 07:09:10 UTC
Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Mariss Freimanis
2006-12-18 08:30:26 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
turbulatordude
2006-12-18 09:00:14 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 09:13:32 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
turbulatordude
2006-12-18 10:14:19 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
caudlet
2006-12-18 10:31:11 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 11:06:01 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Mariss Freimanis
2006-12-18 11:20:22 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 11:45:42 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Fred Smith
2006-12-18 11:45:55 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
C.S. Mo
2006-12-18 12:14:34 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
atelierrobin
2006-12-18 12:22:02 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 12:32:27 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Leslie Newell
2006-12-18 12:39:43 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 12:41:58 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 12:53:38 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
atelierrobin
2006-12-18 12:58:12 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Mark Vaughan
2006-12-18 13:05:57 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 13:08:38 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
John Dammeyer
2006-12-18 14:20:46 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Tony Smith
2006-12-18 14:25:18 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-18 14:33:30 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Leslie Newell
2006-12-18 14:46:59 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Leslie Newell
2006-12-18 14:48:02 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Fred Smith
2006-12-18 15:01:55 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
John Dammeyer
2006-12-18 15:16:54 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Jon Elson
2006-12-18 20:47:23 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Jon Elson
2006-12-18 20:47:37 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
turbulatordude
2006-12-19 04:58:10 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-19 05:15:37 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-19 05:29:33 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Jon Elson
2006-12-19 07:59:03 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Graham Stabler
2006-12-19 08:38:12 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
lcdpublishing
2006-12-19 08:56:42 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Graham Stabler
2006-12-19 09:46:05 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
optics22000
2006-12-19 10:27:16 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
John Dammeyer
2006-12-19 11:04:49 UTC
CNCing a 7x12 minilathe
Graham Stabler
2006-12-19 12:06:19 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?
Peter Homann
2006-12-19 12:12:22 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] CNCing a 7x12 minilathe
John Dammeyer
2006-12-19 12:47:34 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] CNCing a 7x12 minilathe
David Bloomfield
2006-12-20 04:09:10 UTC
Re: Why is the push to such high step rates (Grex and Arc100)?