Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
    Posted by
    
      jeffalanp
    
  
  
    on 2002-11-17 20:56:41 UTC
  
  Hello Peter,
When you run stepper motors in bipolar mode you will be driving
twice the amount of copper (compared to unipolar). This turns into
TWO times the resistance, and FOUR times the inductance the drive has
to overcome, thus the time to fully energize the coils will DOUBLE.
As you start getting faster and faster step rates, your drive doesn't
have time to fully charge/discharge the current in the coils to the
proper level. Thus at HIGHER step rates bipolar can end up having
less torque than unipolar (given equivalent voltages for both
drives).
The good news is that the holding torque, or torque at slower step
rates will be about 1.414 times MORE than a unipolar drive. This is
where most of the power is really needed; when cutting metal at the
slower, non-rapid feed rates.
If you can find datasheets for your motor, they might show torque
curves for both unipolar and bipolar. You can go from there when
deciding on whether to choose a bipolar or unipolar drive.
Jeff
www.xylotex.com
The XS-3525/8S-3 is a bipolar 3 Axis 2.5Amp 35Volt Stepper Driver
board
When you run stepper motors in bipolar mode you will be driving
twice the amount of copper (compared to unipolar). This turns into
TWO times the resistance, and FOUR times the inductance the drive has
to overcome, thus the time to fully energize the coils will DOUBLE.
As you start getting faster and faster step rates, your drive doesn't
have time to fully charge/discharge the current in the coils to the
proper level. Thus at HIGHER step rates bipolar can end up having
less torque than unipolar (given equivalent voltages for both
drives).
The good news is that the holding torque, or torque at slower step
rates will be about 1.414 times MORE than a unipolar drive. This is
where most of the power is really needed; when cutting metal at the
slower, non-rapid feed rates.
If you can find datasheets for your motor, they might show torque
curves for both unipolar and bipolar. You can go from there when
deciding on whether to choose a bipolar or unipolar drive.
Jeff
www.xylotex.com
The XS-3525/8S-3 is a bipolar 3 Axis 2.5Amp 35Volt Stepper Driver
board
--- In CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@y..., "Peter Homann" <peter.homann@a...> wrote:
> Hi,
>
> I am thinking of running my 200 oz/in Unipolar steppers from a
bipolar
> controller. Can anybody provide advice on what sort of power/speed
reduction
> I can expect?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Peter Homann
> mailto:Peter.Homann@a...
> Adacel Technologies Limited,
> 250 Bay St, BRIGHTON, 3186, AUSTRALIA
> http://www.adacel.com <http://www.adacel.com>
> Telephone +61 (3) 8530 7777, Facsimile +61 (3) 9596 2960
> Mobile 0421-601 665
Discussion Thread
  
    Ken Jenkins
  
2002-11-03 08:43:30 UTC
  Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    wenger2k
  
2002-11-03 10:46:36 UTC
  Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Fred Smith
  
2002-11-03 11:28:42 UTC
  Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    alenz2002
  
2002-11-03 12:52:57 UTC
  Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Alan Marconett KM6VV
  
2002-11-03 15:58:20 UTC
  Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Ray Henry
  
2002-11-03 17:38:09 UTC
  Re: Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Fred Smith
  
2002-11-03 18:06:36 UTC
  Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Ray Henry
  
2002-11-04 04:40:06 UTC
  Re: Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    IMService
  
2002-11-04 06:17:20 UTC
  Re: Re: Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    allan_reinhard
  
2002-11-04 11:06:09 UTC
  Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Ray Henry
  
2002-11-04 18:58:47 UTC
  Re: Re: Re: Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Raymond Heckert
  
2002-11-04 19:15:19 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    bjammin@i...
  
2002-11-05 05:06:55 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Ray Henry
  
2002-11-05 09:21:37 UTC
  Re: Re: Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    Dan Mauch
  
2002-11-05 10:16:58 UTC
  DRO Boards
  
    bjammin@i...
  
2002-11-05 14:39:00 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Re: Re: Polar Coordinates CNC?
  
    macfool68
  
2002-11-12 16:45:59 UTC
  Re: DRO Boards
  
    Van Der Sandt Coert
  
2002-11-12 23:05:20 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    Dan Mauch
  
2002-11-13 06:38:47 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    macfool68
  
2002-11-13 06:52:17 UTC
  Re: DRO Boards
  
    Dan Mauch
  
2002-11-13 07:14:42 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    Dan Mauch
  
2002-11-13 07:28:16 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    Tim Goldstein
  
2002-11-13 09:11:12 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    j.guenther
  
2002-11-13 09:22:49 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    aussiedude
  
2002-11-13 09:29:31 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    Dan Mauch
  
2002-11-13 10:31:44 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    Dan Mauch
  
2002-11-14 12:56:05 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: DRO Boards
  
    Peter Homann
  
2002-11-17 16:59:38 UTC
  Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    turbulatordude
  
2002-11-17 17:27:23 UTC
  Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    jeffalanp
  
2002-11-17 20:56:41 UTC
  Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    Tim Goldstein
  
2002-11-17 22:59:27 UTC
  RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    Jon Elson
  
2002-11-18 08:09:41 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    jeffalanp
  
2002-11-18 09:40:29 UTC
  Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    Tim Goldstein
  
2002-11-18 10:35:42 UTC
  Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    mariss92705
  
2002-11-18 17:07:08 UTC
  Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    jeffalanp
  
2002-11-18 21:56:32 UTC
  Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    mariss92705
  
2002-11-19 10:59:15 UTC
  Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?
  
    jeffalanp
  
2002-11-20 22:40:35 UTC
  Re: Running Unipolar steppers with a Bi-polar driver?