RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Posted by
David Howland
on 1999-09-14 15:26:19 UTC
Okay. At what wind speed will you head for shelter? Thanks for your data.
I am interested in finding or developing what I have described. If no one finds any value in what I am looking for, I will purchase what I need as components or systems. If several people identify with the idea that spending under $700 in total to upgrade an older mill is something worth while, then I may develop a kit for their efforts.
I'm not ready to do anything. I'm still listening to many members, including yourself, with a lot more practical experience than myself. After all, You can't really say I'm crazy unless I actually do something crazy. So far, there is about a 50 - 50 chance. I live in California, 12 miles from the San Andreas fault. They don't give us any warnings, and they don't call em by catagories.
From: Bertho Boman <boman@...>
To create a "home shop" real servo system, as far as I see it, there are two pieces that needs special attention: Computer I-O and servo amps.
Computer I-O:
Commercially, at least Servo-to-Go is available but our goal would be to come up with a low cost alternative. I have not researched what is available or who is doing what. How many channels do we need for a reasonable home system? 4??
Each channel probably would consist of:
Input for an encoder A, B, Index, Home, Limit-1, Limit-2
Output for servo amp=D-A +/- 10VDC, servo On/Off
An extra D-A with +/- 10VDC for spindle speed (actually use only 0-10 VDC)
Digital undedicated I-O: 8 input and 8 outputs for pumps, clamps switches or what ever.
Servo Amplifier:
Jon Elson has already designed and build one and he apparently has boards more or less available. That sounds very tempting and I will take a look at his design and see if it will fit my need. I have some Copley commercial amps here but I am trying to get people working together and we can achieve a lot if we go in the same direction. On the servo amp, the big issue is power and do we get high current at relatively low voltage or high voltage at relatively low current or of course everyone wants both at the same time.
Bertho Boman
===========================================
David Howland wrote:
Free Games & Cash Prizes!
Gamesville - The World's Biggest & Best Game Show Site!
<a href=" http://clickme.onelist.com/ad/gamesville2 ">Click Here</a>
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Welcome to CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@...,an unmoderated list for the discussion of shop built systems in the above catagories.
To Unsubscribe, read archives, change to or from digest.
Go to: http://www.onelist.com/isregistered.cgi
Log on, and you will go to Member Center, and you can make changes there.
For the FAQ, go to http://www.ktmarketing.com/faq.html
bill,
List Manager
I am interested in finding or developing what I have described. If no one finds any value in what I am looking for, I will purchase what I need as components or systems. If several people identify with the idea that spending under $700 in total to upgrade an older mill is something worth while, then I may develop a kit for their efforts.
I'm not ready to do anything. I'm still listening to many members, including yourself, with a lot more practical experience than myself. After all, You can't really say I'm crazy unless I actually do something crazy. So far, there is about a 50 - 50 chance. I live in California, 12 miles from the San Andreas fault. They don't give us any warnings, and they don't call em by catagories.
From: Bertho Boman <boman@...>
To create a "home shop" real servo system, as far as I see it, there are two pieces that needs special attention: Computer I-O and servo amps.
Computer I-O:
Commercially, at least Servo-to-Go is available but our goal would be to come up with a low cost alternative. I have not researched what is available or who is doing what. How many channels do we need for a reasonable home system? 4??
Each channel probably would consist of:
Input for an encoder A, B, Index, Home, Limit-1, Limit-2
Output for servo amp=D-A +/- 10VDC, servo On/Off
An extra D-A with +/- 10VDC for spindle speed (actually use only 0-10 VDC)
Digital undedicated I-O: 8 input and 8 outputs for pumps, clamps switches or what ever.
Servo Amplifier:
Jon Elson has already designed and build one and he apparently has boards more or less available. That sounds very tempting and I will take a look at his design and see if it will fit my need. I have some Copley commercial amps here but I am trying to get people working together and we can achieve a lot if we go in the same direction. On the servo amp, the big issue is power and do we get high current at relatively low voltage or high voltage at relatively low current or of course everyone wants both at the same time.
Bertho Boman
===========================================
David Howland wrote:
> From: David Howland <dhowland@...>--------------------------- ONElist Sponsor ----------------------------
> --------- >Snip
> If you believe a high performance low cost servo system is more appropriate and has not already been done, what would be the goals for such a system? I mean of course, after you are finished having a huricane there in Florida.
>
> David Howland
Free Games & Cash Prizes!
Gamesville - The World's Biggest & Best Game Show Site!
<a href=" http://clickme.onelist.com/ad/gamesville2 ">Click Here</a>
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Welcome to CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@...,an unmoderated list for the discussion of shop built systems in the above catagories.
To Unsubscribe, read archives, change to or from digest.
Go to: http://www.onelist.com/isregistered.cgi
Log on, and you will go to Member Center, and you can make changes there.
For the FAQ, go to http://www.ktmarketing.com/faq.html
bill,
List Manager
Discussion Thread
David Howland
1999-09-10 12:24:44 UTC
Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@a...
1999-09-10 15:48:31 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-10 17:07:57 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Andy Olney
1999-09-10 19:34:45 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-10 21:19:13 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-12 22:42:24 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-13 13:34:08 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-13 14:49:40 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-13 15:26:10 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Mo
1999-09-13 14:31:40 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-13 16:08:55 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-13 18:09:21 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@a...
1999-09-13 16:36:02 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-13 17:41:39 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
CG
1999-09-13 18:06:05 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Dan Falck
1999-09-13 19:00:45 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@a...
1999-09-13 21:44:43 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-13 22:52:12 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-13 23:52:43 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-14 09:03:57 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Kirk W. Fraser
1999-09-14 10:00:49 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-14 10:06:39 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
George Potter
1999-09-14 10:41:57 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-14 11:04:16 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-14 11:44:55 UTC
RE: Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-14 12:21:12 UTC
Low cost Servo Controller
Matt Shaver
1999-09-14 12:42:53 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-14 12:58:25 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-14 13:01:16 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-14 12:53:19 UTC
Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-14 13:05:48 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-14 13:20:37 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-14 15:26:19 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-14 16:43:25 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-14 15:31:48 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Ian Wright
1999-09-14 15:42:11 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-14 16:11:54 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-14 16:20:15 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-14 17:40:37 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@x...
1999-09-14 16:32:29 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@x...
1999-09-14 16:34:15 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@x...
1999-09-14 16:36:36 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-14 18:03:13 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
garfield@x...
1999-09-14 18:39:50 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Dan Falck
1999-09-14 18:10:27 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-14 19:09:34 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-14 23:07:45 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-14 23:16:59 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-14 23:21:04 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-14 23:42:00 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-14 23:36:26 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-15 03:54:15 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-15 04:00:36 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Ray Henry
1999-09-15 06:19:49 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-15 07:49:52 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-15 07:52:54 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-15 08:16:04 UTC
Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller
David Howland
1999-09-15 10:11:41 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-15 13:35:35 UTC
Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller
F. de Beer
1999-09-15 14:52:43 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-15 15:23:54 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
CG
1999-09-16 10:02:58 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-16 15:39:09 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Tom Kulaga
1999-09-16 17:06:29 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-16 19:40:10 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-16 22:40:26 UTC
Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Dean Franks
1999-09-17 00:32:44 UTC
Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-17 04:43:03 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Darrell Gehlsen
1999-09-17 22:44:49 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
CG
1999-09-18 08:28:21 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Mike Gann
1999-09-18 09:47:15 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Dean Franks
1999-09-18 12:40:43 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
CG
1999-09-18 14:23:16 UTC
RE: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-18 21:03:37 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-18 22:38:48 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-18 21:40:59 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Matt Shaver
1999-09-18 22:05:11 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Dean Franks
1999-09-18 23:09:04 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
John Craddock
1999-09-19 04:28:15 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-19 04:27:59 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Pete Dunster
1999-09-19 05:48:20 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Les Watts
1999-09-19 07:32:37 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-19 09:28:21 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Steve Carlisle
1999-09-19 09:38:53 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Dean Franks
1999-09-19 11:21:32 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-19 13:28:28 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-19 21:49:09 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-19 22:05:46 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-19 22:25:23 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-20 04:22:28 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Leslie Watts
1999-09-20 12:47:55 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Leslie Watts
1999-09-20 12:59:48 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@x...
1999-09-20 13:55:27 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Bertho Boman
1999-09-20 14:11:43 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-20 16:05:20 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Peter Bailey
1999-09-20 16:56:10 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Leslie Watts
1999-09-21 08:17:58 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
PTENGIN@a...
1999-09-21 10:04:48 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-21 13:03:23 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Leslie Watts
1999-09-21 13:46:58 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Les Watts
1999-09-22 07:25:34 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Jon Elson
1999-09-22 12:18:19 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller
Stephen Barmash
1999-09-23 17:13:28 UTC
Re: Low cost Servo Controller