CAD CAM EDM DRO - Yahoo Group Archive

Re: Low cost Servo Controller

Posted by Jon Elson
on 1999-09-19 22:05:46 UTC
Les Watts wrote:

> I suspect EMC with the STG card will outperform LM628/9 systems which is why i'm here. The
> big cnc router I am building uses very high feed rates and following error is a big issue.

With the feedforward terms in the EMC motion control section, I think you can get following error
VERY close to zero. I got it so low, that I just stopped tinkering with it. Staying within a few thousanths
of an inch all the way up to 100 IPM, including the acceleration ramp was good enough at the time!

> I have a comment on the servo power amp-
> About a year ago I designed and built a large analog power amp (current limit is set at 20 amps!)
> and it took a month of weekends to get it going. But companies like Copley Controls sell a 12 amp
> h-bridge pwm amp for about $275. They will accept analog or pwm input I believe. I think I will just
> buy them rather than roll my own.

Well, Copely's prices must have come WAY down, or you have a special deal with them. The prices
I remember seeing are quite a bit higher that that. (But, I admit, they've been coming out with new
models quite regularly.)

> It makes more sense for me to be doing things like ball screw end machining right now.

Just don't do like me, and cut the precision ball screw an inch too short! Arrgh!
(I was able to use it, but it took a lot of head scratching to make it still work.)

Jon

Discussion Thread

David Howland 1999-09-10 12:24:44 UTC Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-10 15:48:31 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-10 17:07:57 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Andy Olney 1999-09-10 19:34:45 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-10 21:19:13 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-12 22:42:24 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-13 13:34:08 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-13 14:49:40 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-13 15:26:10 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Mo 1999-09-13 14:31:40 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-13 16:08:55 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-13 18:09:21 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-13 16:36:02 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-13 17:41:39 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-13 18:06:05 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Dan Falck 1999-09-13 19:00:45 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-13 21:44:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-13 22:52:12 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-13 23:52:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 09:03:57 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Kirk W. Fraser 1999-09-14 10:00:49 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 10:06:39 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller George Potter 1999-09-14 10:41:57 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 11:04:16 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 11:44:55 UTC RE: Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 12:21:12 UTC Low cost Servo Controller Matt Shaver 1999-09-14 12:42:53 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 12:58:25 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 13:01:16 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 12:53:19 UTC Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 13:05:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 13:20:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 15:26:19 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-14 16:43:25 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 15:31:48 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Ian Wright 1999-09-14 15:42:11 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 16:11:54 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 16:20:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-14 17:40:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-14 16:32:29 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-14 16:34:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-14 16:36:36 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-14 18:03:13 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller garfield@x... 1999-09-14 18:39:50 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dan Falck 1999-09-14 18:10:27 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 19:09:34 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:07:45 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:16:59 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:21:04 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:42:00 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 23:36:26 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-15 03:54:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-15 04:00:36 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Ray Henry 1999-09-15 06:19:49 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-15 07:49:52 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-15 07:52:54 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-15 08:16:04 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-15 10:11:41 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-15 13:35:35 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller F. de Beer 1999-09-15 14:52:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-15 15:23:54 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-16 10:02:58 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-16 15:39:09 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Tom Kulaga 1999-09-16 17:06:29 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-16 19:40:10 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-16 22:40:26 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-17 00:32:44 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-17 04:43:03 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Darrell Gehlsen 1999-09-17 22:44:49 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-18 08:28:21 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Mike Gann 1999-09-18 09:47:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-18 12:40:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-18 14:23:16 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-18 21:03:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-18 22:38:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-18 21:40:59 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Matt Shaver 1999-09-18 22:05:11 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-18 23:09:04 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller John Craddock 1999-09-19 04:28:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-19 04:27:59 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Pete Dunster 1999-09-19 05:48:20 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Les Watts 1999-09-19 07:32:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-19 09:28:21 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-19 09:38:53 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-19 11:21:32 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-19 13:28:28 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-19 21:49:09 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-19 22:05:46 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-19 22:25:23 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-20 04:22:28 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-20 12:47:55 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-20 12:59:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-20 13:55:27 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-20 14:11:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-20 16:05:20 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Peter Bailey 1999-09-20 16:56:10 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-21 08:17:58 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-21 10:04:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-21 13:03:23 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-21 13:46:58 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Les Watts 1999-09-22 07:25:34 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-22 12:18:19 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Stephen Barmash 1999-09-23 17:13:28 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller