CAD CAM EDM DRO - Yahoo Group Archive

Re: Low cost Servo Controller

Posted by Les Watts
on 1999-09-22 07:25:34 UTC
Oops, my last post didn't come through.

Jon,

The center of mass and center of percussion of the structure are far from the spindle so the 800 lbs
inertia /gravity force will tend to more stress the base which is built into the floor.

I will put some pictures on the web site as soon as the z axis is mounted to the y axis. Right now
I am cleaning up and installing a Boxford VSL lathe with Themac tool post grinder to expedite
the ballscrew end machining.

Anyway the structure is built so the deflections will be what they will be. It is the most rigid
that budget and engineering analysis will allow.

I would like to learn what the best controls will allow as far as high speed performance. My lm628
software was tested with a small xyz voice coil driven machine and the very best I can do (following
tech80 advice) is 1000 microsecond trajectory updates. If EMC can do 200 microsecond servo
updates I would think one could go 5 times faster or one fifth following error given the proper
amp and encoder. Perhaps even better considering feedforward.



--
Leslie M.Watts
Illinois Tool Works
Corporate Advanced Technology group
(847) 657-4559
http://www.netcom.com/~leswatts/leswp.html

Discussion Thread

David Howland 1999-09-10 12:24:44 UTC Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-10 15:48:31 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-10 17:07:57 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Andy Olney 1999-09-10 19:34:45 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-10 21:19:13 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-12 22:42:24 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-13 13:34:08 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-13 14:49:40 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-13 15:26:10 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Mo 1999-09-13 14:31:40 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-13 16:08:55 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-13 18:09:21 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-13 16:36:02 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-13 17:41:39 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-13 18:06:05 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Dan Falck 1999-09-13 19:00:45 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-13 21:44:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-13 22:52:12 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-13 23:52:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 09:03:57 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Kirk W. Fraser 1999-09-14 10:00:49 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 10:06:39 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller George Potter 1999-09-14 10:41:57 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 11:04:16 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 11:44:55 UTC RE: Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 12:21:12 UTC Low cost Servo Controller Matt Shaver 1999-09-14 12:42:53 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 12:58:25 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 13:01:16 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 12:53:19 UTC Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 13:05:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 13:20:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 15:26:19 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-14 16:43:25 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-14 15:31:48 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Ian Wright 1999-09-14 15:42:11 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 16:11:54 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 16:20:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-14 17:40:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-14 16:32:29 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-14 16:34:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-14 16:36:36 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-14 18:03:13 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller garfield@x... 1999-09-14 18:39:50 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dan Falck 1999-09-14 18:10:27 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 19:09:34 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:07:45 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:16:59 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:21:04 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-14 23:42:00 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-14 23:36:26 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-15 03:54:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-15 04:00:36 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Ray Henry 1999-09-15 06:19:49 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-15 07:49:52 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-15 07:52:54 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-15 08:16:04 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller David Howland 1999-09-15 10:11:41 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-15 13:35:35 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller F. de Beer 1999-09-15 14:52:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-15 15:23:54 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-16 10:02:58 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-16 15:39:09 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Tom Kulaga 1999-09-16 17:06:29 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-16 19:40:10 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-16 22:40:26 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-17 00:32:44 UTC Re: Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-17 04:43:03 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Darrell Gehlsen 1999-09-17 22:44:49 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-18 08:28:21 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Mike Gann 1999-09-18 09:47:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-18 12:40:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller CG 1999-09-18 14:23:16 UTC RE: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-18 21:03:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-18 22:38:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-18 21:40:59 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Matt Shaver 1999-09-18 22:05:11 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-18 23:09:04 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller John Craddock 1999-09-19 04:28:15 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-19 04:27:59 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Pete Dunster 1999-09-19 05:48:20 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Les Watts 1999-09-19 07:32:37 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-19 09:28:21 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Steve Carlisle 1999-09-19 09:38:53 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Dean Franks 1999-09-19 11:21:32 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-19 13:28:28 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-19 21:49:09 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-19 22:05:46 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-19 22:25:23 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-20 04:22:28 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-20 12:47:55 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-20 12:59:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@x... 1999-09-20 13:55:27 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Bertho Boman 1999-09-20 14:11:43 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-20 16:05:20 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Peter Bailey 1999-09-20 16:56:10 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-21 08:17:58 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller PTENGIN@a... 1999-09-21 10:04:48 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-21 13:03:23 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Leslie Watts 1999-09-21 13:46:58 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Les Watts 1999-09-22 07:25:34 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Jon Elson 1999-09-22 12:18:19 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller Stephen Barmash 1999-09-23 17:13:28 UTC Re: Low cost Servo Controller