Re: Max 10 questions.
Posted by
Charles Hixon
on 2003-06-24 22:46:17 UTC
If this is the Max 10 mill is the one being announced on the Max NC
site for $1600, which seems a coincidence if it isn't, then the
seller was representing this to be a CL (closed loop) servo model,
which is sold new for around $2300 I think. (I won't check - slow
bandwidth) If so and the seller is honest, it isn't quite as bad a
deal as I'm reading in responses here, But I'm not familar with the
mill.
I have this same MaxNC 10 CL KIT retrofitted to a Sherline mill and
everything from MaxNC works fine, no surprises. I chose Sherline
because of the larger Z-axis bite that I needed.
Cost for this servo system: mill: $660 (through a Sherline dealer -
(I received the fancy adjustable handwheels with it) + MaxNC 10 CL
KIT: around $825. Everything went together fine. Otto at MaxNC
answered all my dumb setup questions and I'm on my WinXP computer
working fine in Gcode, no surprises. Beat that price
$660+around$825=$1485 for a SERVO system.
Charles
site for $1600, which seems a coincidence if it isn't, then the
seller was representing this to be a CL (closed loop) servo model,
which is sold new for around $2300 I think. (I won't check - slow
bandwidth) If so and the seller is honest, it isn't quite as bad a
deal as I'm reading in responses here, But I'm not familar with the
mill.
I have this same MaxNC 10 CL KIT retrofitted to a Sherline mill and
everything from MaxNC works fine, no surprises. I chose Sherline
because of the larger Z-axis bite that I needed.
Cost for this servo system: mill: $660 (through a Sherline dealer -
(I received the fancy adjustable handwheels with it) + MaxNC 10 CL
KIT: around $825. Everything went together fine. Otto at MaxNC
answered all my dumb setup questions and I'm on my WinXP computer
working fine in Gcode, no surprises. Beat that price
$660+around$825=$1485 for a SERVO system.
Charles
--- In CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO@yahoogroups.com, wanliker@a... wrote:
> Can someone give me information on a Max 10?
> I have a chance at one for $1600, and want to know if it is a good
buy or
> not.
> It has the following:
> Max 10 Mill, Seems to have no use on it, very clean and no
scratches or
> wear apparent on the bed.
> Steppers Powermax 11, P22NRXG, 1.8 dig per step. 55 V, 5 Amp,
Nema 23,
> BiPolar.
>
> BSA Backlashscrews, with couplers.
>
> The unit is complete with control box, software, and some collets.
>
> I would like to know any information, that anyone can share with
me.
>
> Current estimated value?
> Size of Steppers? Are these simple steppers, or multiphase
steppers?
> Can this be used easily with other software?
> How hard would it be to drive this machine with better
software???? Step and
> Direction desired, or possibly Servos?
> bill
> CCED
>
>
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Discussion Thread
wanliker@a...
2003-06-24 15:31:51 UTC
Max 10 questions.
Alan Marconett KM6VV
2003-06-24 15:53:50 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Max 10 questions.
John Guenther
2003-06-24 17:05:25 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Max 10 questions.
Jon Anderson
2003-06-24 17:11:26 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Max 10 questions.
John Guenther
2003-06-24 17:28:03 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Max 10 questions.
Tim Goldstein
2003-06-24 17:39:16 UTC
RE: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Max 10 questions.
Jon Anderson
2003-06-24 17:48:51 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Max 10 questions.
Alan Marconett KM6VV
2003-06-24 18:17:39 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Max 10 questions.
wanliker@a...
2003-06-24 19:57:47 UTC
Max 10 questions.
Charles Hixon
2003-06-24 22:45:20 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Charles Hixon
2003-06-24 22:45:29 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Charles Hixon
2003-06-24 22:46:17 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
stevenson_engineers
2003-06-25 00:33:13 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
mmurray701
2003-06-25 04:23:18 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Fred Smith
2003-06-25 06:02:12 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Charles Hixon
2003-06-25 07:46:48 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Fred Smith
2003-06-25 09:36:45 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Andrew Werby
2003-06-25 09:55:43 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Charles Hixon
2003-06-25 12:14:36 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
wanliker@a...
2003-06-25 17:31:08 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Max 10 questions.
Ron Steele
2003-06-25 18:33:35 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Charles Hixon
2003-06-26 07:41:33 UTC
Re: Max 10 questions.
Matt Shaver
2003-06-26 11:31:42 UTC
Re: [CAD_CAM_EDM_DRO] Re: Max 10 questions.